The five, on the makers' own figures
| Grill | Published cooking area | Shape | Build | Warranty | Who it suits |
|---|
| Weber Original Kettle 22 in | 363 sq in | Round kettle on legs | Porcelain-enameled bowl and lid, plated steel grate | 10 years, bowl and lid | A yard, and anyone cooking for four or more |
| Weber Smokey Joe 14 in | Not published on this listing | Round kettle, tabletop | Porcelain-enameled bowl and lid | Not published on this listing | A balcony, a campsite, or a first grill on a budget |
| Royal Gourmet CD1824M 24 in | 490 sq in total (384 main + 106 warming) | Barrel on a cart with a folding side table | Porcelain-enameled steel wire grates, 40.1 lb | Not comparable to Weber’s decade cover | The most grate area at the lowest sensible price |
| Weber Jumbo Joe 18 in | 18-inch grate; sq in not published on this listing | Round kettle with lid lock | Porcelain-enameled bowl and lid | Not published on this listing | A portable that still feeds four or five |
| Weber Go-Anywhere | Not published on this listing | Rectangular, folding legs | Porcelain-enameled steel | Not published on this listing | Sausages, corn and skewers; picnic tables |
The blank cells are the makers’ doing, not ours. Weber publishes a square- inch figure and a warranty on the full-size kettle and declines to on the three portables we read, so those stay blank rather than borrowing a number from a retailer.
Why the 22-inch kettle wins this band outright
Three reasons, in order of how much they matter.
- It is a full-size grill, not a small one. 363 square inches is the same bowl and lid as the kettles that cost considerably more — the Premium and the Master-Touch add fittings, not cooking room. You are not buying a cut-down version of anything.
- Weber publishes ten years on the bowl and lid. Against rust-through and burn-through specifically. Nothing else at this price carries cover remotely like that, and the parts network behind it means a grate or a handle years from now is a part rather than a new grill.
- It does both jobs. Spread the coals and it sears. Bank them to one side, close the lid and it is an indirect chamber — which is all smoking is, mechanically. Our guide to smoking on a charcoal grill walks through it, and best grill smoker combos sets a kettle against the cookers built for it.
Two honest gaps. Weber does not list a built-in lid thermometer on this model, and a clip-on one costs very little. The grate is plated steel and is not listed as hinged, so topping up coals means lifting food off — a pair of charcoal baskets solves the related two-zone problem for a few dollars. Our kettle versus Master-Touch comparison covers exactly what the dearer kettles add.
When to buy the barrel instead
The Royal Gourmet CD1824M is the one non-Weber here and it earns its place on one number: 490 square inches total, including a 106-square-inch stainless warming rack, which is meaningfully more grate than the 22-inch kettle. It also has a crank that raises and lowers the charcoal pan — genuinely the most useful control on a budget charcoal grill, because it changes the heat without rebuilding the fire — plus a lid thermometer, dual vents and a folding side table.
Be clear-eyed about what that costs. The grates are porcelain-enameled steel wire rather than cast iron, so they hold far less heat and leave fainter marks. Royal Gourmet lists a 4.5 lb charcoal capacity, which is not built for a multi-hour low cook. And 40 pounds spread across a 40-inch body is light-gauge steel, so it will shed heat on a cold or windy day. It is an honest five-year grill, not a twenty-year one.
The three portables, and which is which
Weber makes three small charcoal grills and they are not interchangeable.
- Smokey Joe (14 in). The kettle shrunk, with a carry handle. Cooks for two or three. No lid thermometer and no ash catcher at this size. The cheapest genuine Weber there is.
- Jumbo Joe (18 in). Eighteen inches of grate with a lid lock and a carry handle — enough depth to bank coals to one side for indirect heat, and enough grate for a real dinner. It is a two-hands carry and has no leg stand, so it needs a table or the ground.
- Go-Anywhere. Rectangular, which matters more than it sounds: sausages, corn and skewers fit far better than in a small round bowl. Legs fold over the lid so it carries like a case. Shallower than a kettle, so less room for indirect cooking.
Wider options, including gas portables, are in best portable grills, and gifts for apartment grillers covers the balcony case specifically — worth reading first, because a lot of apartment blocks ban charcoal outright.
Budget for the fire, not just the grill
A charcoal grill is only half the purchase, and the other half is cheap enough that skipping it makes no sense.
- A chimney starter. This is the object this site is named after and the single change that most improves charcoal food, because it lights coals with newspaper instead of fluid. See best charcoal chimney starters and chimney starter versus lighter fluid.
- Charcoal. Briquettes for a steady predictable fire, lump when you want the grate screaming hot. Best charcoal for grilling compares the bags on published figures.
- A thermometer. A lid thermometer reads the air; the number that decides dinner is inside the meat. Thermometers under $50 covers the whole useful range.
- A cover, eventually. Porcelain enamel is tough but ash and standing water are not kind to anything. Grill covers sorts by published fit.
How much charcoal, and how to control it
The two questions that follow immediately after buying a charcoal grill both have published answers rather than opinions. Kingsford publishes a quantity chart measured in chimneys, stating that a standard chimney holds about 100 briquets or roughly four pounds: for a 22-inch grill, about half to three-quarters of a chimney for medium heat, a full chimney for high heat, and a quarter to half a chimney banked to one side for indirect cooking.
Weber’s own guidance on control is that the top vent goes fully open for high heat and roughly a quarter open for low, with the bottom bowl vents left open so the fire does not die. For kettle smoking specifically it targets around 250°F and says swings between 225 and 275°F are fine. Our guides to how much charcoal to use and charcoal grill vents work through both in full.
Half this budget is its own band. Best portable grills under $100 covers what a hundred dollars buys — three genuine Weber portables and the cheapest gas grill on this site — and best Royal Gourmet grills covers the brand that offers the most published grate area anywhere near this price.