Char Chimney

Grilling Gear Guides

The product roundups behind the gift lists — the best tools, thermometers, gloves and grills, compared on what actually matters.

Behind every gift list on Char Chimney is a product roundup, and this is where they live. If you already know you want “the best thermometer” or “a good tool set” rather than a gift by budget or recipient, start here. These guides compare the real products in each category on the things that actually matter — not marketing numbers — and every pick carries its live price and a buy link.

The categories worth their own guide

Thermometers are the most important grilling tool there is, and the range runs from a $10 instant-read to a $80 wireless smart probe. The right one depends entirely on how they cook: a fast pocket instant-read for everyday grilling, a multi-probe or wireless unit for long smokes. Compare the thermometers.

Tool sets are the default grilling gift, and quality varies wildly — the thing that matters is thick, non-flexing stainless and a sensible number of pieces rather than a 30-piece case of filler. See the tool sets. Gloves are the underrated one: almost nobody owns a good pair, and heat rating, forearm reach and material (silicone versus neoprene versus a cut-resistant weave) are what separate them. Compare the gloves.

Accessories — brushes, chimney starters, baskets, lights, mats — are where the genuinely thoughtful cheap gifts hide. See the accessories. And if the gift is a whole grill, the choice between gas, charcoal and a flat-top griddle is really a choice about how someone wants to cook. See the best grills for beginners.

Once the fuel is settled, each side has a guide of its own. Best gas grills compares propane on footprint, burner zones and parts availability, while best charcoal grills sorts kettles, barrels, kamados and offsets by the three things that actually decide whether a charcoal grill is any good: airflow control, grate area and how the ash comes out. And for the cook who wants smoked food without tending a fire, best pellet grills compares Traeger, Pit Boss and recteq on searing heat, hopper size and whether the app is worth paying for. And for the cook whose favorite food is smash burgers, breakfast or anything that would fall through a grate, best flat top griddles ranks eight gas griddles on plate size, how many burner zones run independently and whether a lid comes in the box.

If the fuel is not settled yet, three guides work across all of them. Best grills under $500 puts gas, charcoal, pellet, kamado and a griddle on one page and picks the best of each at the most useful budget there is. Best grills for searing steak judges them on heat alone, for the cook who buys a grill for steak. And best smokers for beginners ranks pellet, kamado, kettle and offset by how easy each is to learn.

One category sits outside the cooker and the tool drawer alike: knives. Almost every griller owns tongs and almost none owns a long blade, which is why a brisket smoked for twelve hours so often gets carved with an eight-inch chef’s knife. Best BBQ knives splits the category by the two jobs barbecue actually has — trimming it raw with a short flexible blade, slicing it cooked with a long rigid one — and compares eight picks from an eleven-inch slicer to a fourteen-inch Solingen blade on length, edge type and the hardness and angle figures each maker does or does not publish.

Two more categories sit either side of the cooker and get overlooked for opposite reasons. Charcoal is the thing a charcoal griller buys over and over without ever researching, and it costs more across five years than the grill did. Best charcoal for grilling sets briquettes against lump and compares six bags on what each maker is actually willing to publish — burn times, bag weight, binders and ash — including the brand that quotes two different peak temperatures on its own website. Covers are the opposite: bought once, never thought about, and the cheapest thing that makes a grill last longer. Best grill covers compares seven on published fit dimensions, fabric and warranty — universal, kettle, pellet, griddle and kamado — and explains how to measure for one without ruining the surprise.

How we compare things

We don’t run a test lab, and we don’t pretend to. We compile the published specs, read the consensus of what real owners report, pull the live price, and judge each product on giftability — broad appeal, easy returns, and usefulness across skill levels. Where we’d skip something, we say so. That method is spelled out in full on our how we pick page. If you’d rather shop by budget or by recipient, the budget and recipient guides draw from these same roundups.

And once a category guide has narrowed you down to one or two products, the reviews and comparisons go a level deeper — a single product examined properly, or two laid side by side in a table, each with an honest reason to walk away.

New in October 2026: best meat thermometers for smoking splits off the one job the general thermometer roundup is the wrong page for. A long cook needs two temperatures — what the meat is doing and what the pit is doing — so that page is organized around probe count, range and whether you can read the thing from indoors at 2am, rather than around how fast it reads a burger.

Also new this month, the two pages this hub was missing either side of a pellet grill. Best wood pellets does for pellet grills what the charcoal page did for kettles: seven bags judged on the wood each maker will actually name, the bag weight (Traeger’s went from 20 lb to 18 without announcing it), and which wood belongs on which food — plus the fact that pellets are not brand-locked to your grill, whatever the packaging implies. Best electric smokers covers the one cooker category this hub had no page for: six plug-in cabinets on published cooking area, temperature range and warranty, including the 275°F ceiling that stops almost all of them crisping poultry skin, and the maker that contradicts itself twice on its own spec sheet.

New on 22 October, the two consumables this hub kept recommending inside other pages without ever having a page for. Best wood chips for smoking sorts the wood aisle by the only question that decides it — chips for a gas grill or an electric cabinet, chunks for charcoal, fine shavings for a stovetop smoker — and matches each wood to the food on the maker’s own terms rather than on a taste test we did not run. Best meat injectors covers the tool that gets flavor into the middle of a turkey or a pork shoulder, from a plain stainless syringe up to a trigger gun — including the USDA labeling rule that exists because pushing a needle through meat carries whatever was on the outside into the middle.

Everything in Gear Guides

Elsewhere on Char Chimney