How we picked, and why BTU is the wrong number
BTU is a fuel-consumption rate, not a measure of how hot a grill gets. Spread 40,000 BTU across 600 square inches and you have a grill that struggles to sear; concentrate 10,000 BTU under 200 square inches with a high dome and cast-iron grates and you have one that does it easily. The only semi-useful version of the number is BTU per square inch of primary grate, and even that is crude, because it says nothing about grate mass, lid shape or how well the burner distributes heat. Here is the arithmetic on the published figures anyway, because it is better than the headline number:
| Grill | Burners | Published BTU | Primary grate | BTU per sq in | Grates |
|---|
| Monument Mesa II 410FBZ | 4 + sear zone | 37,000 | 405 sq in (525 total) | ~91 | Enameled |
| Charbroil Performance 4-burner | 4 + side burner | Not published | 435 sq in (+130 warming) | — | Porcelain cast iron |
| Royal Gourmet GG3001S | 3 independent | 25,500 | 292 sq in (+84 warming) | ~87 | Porcelain cast iron |
| Weber Q 1200N | 1 | 10,000 | 200 sq in | ~50 | Porcelain cast iron |
| Royal Gourmet GD401C combo | 4 independent | 48,000 | 292 grate + 314 flat top | ~79 | Ribbed grate + ceramic flat top |
| Charbroil Classic 2-burner | 2 in-line | 20,000 | 280 sq in (+130 warming) | ~71 | Porcelain-coated wire |
Those per-square-inch figures are our arithmetic on the makers’ own published numbers, not a measurement, and the Weber row is the proof that the ratio is not the whole story — it has the lowest figure here and the heaviest grates relative to its size, under a high dome that holds heat. Treat the column as a sanity check, not a ranking. Charbroil publishes no total BTU for the Performance 4-burner, so that cell stays empty rather than borrowing a figure from a different model.
What we actually ranked on, in order:
- Independently controlled burners. Two is the minimum for a two-zone fire; three is where you get a genuinely cool corner. Royal Gourmet says “independently controlled” in plain words on the GG3001S, which is the claim we want to see. One burner — the Weber — means no two-zone setup at all, and the card says so.
- Cooking area, split honestly. Grills in this band love to add the warming rack into one headline number. We list primary grate and warming rack separately everywhere a maker publishes both, because a warming rack is for holding cooked food, not for cooking on.
- Grate material. Porcelain-enameled cast iron holds and returns heat; porcelain-coated wire does neither as well and chips if you attack it with a wire brush. Four of six here are cast iron, which is more than this band managed a few years ago.
- Published warranty length. The spread is enormous: Monument publishes eight years, Charbroil two on the Performance and one on the Classic, and Royal Gourmet publishes nothing at all on these listings. On a grill that lives outdoors, the warranty is a statement about the firebox and the burners, which are the parts that actually fail.
- Whether the tank is hidden. A cabinet frame enclosing the propane cylinder is worth more than it sounds — it is tidier, the hose is protected, and nothing gets kicked. Three of our picks have one.
Four burners or three? What the extra burner buys
Not much heat, and quite a lot of flexibility. Going from three burners to four in this band typically adds 100–140 square inches and one more independent zone, and it almost always adds width to the cart rather than depth — the Charbroil Performance is a published 53.7 in wide, against roughly 45 in for the three-burner. If the patio is narrow, that is the deciding fact and no amount of grate area fixes it.
The honest case for three burners is that it is the cheapest configuration that does everything: left burner high for searing, right burner off for roasting, middle for the vegetables. The honest case for four is a specific one — you are regularly cooking for more than six people, or you want to hold a whole second zone at a low temperature while the first one runs hot. If neither is true, the money is better spent on a thermometer and tools that are not the ones in the box.
What $300 does not buy
Being clear about the ceiling is more useful than praising the floor. At this price you are not getting any of the following, and no listing in the band will tell you so.
- Stainless that stays looking like stainless. Most of what is called stainless here is a thin skin over painted steel. The lid, the firebox and the grease tray are where corrosion starts, and a cover is a genuinely high-return accessory in this band — see grill covers.
- A sear station that behaves like an infrared burner. Monument’s Broil Zone is a real feature and the best version of the idea in this band, but a dedicated infrared sear burner is a $600-plus feature. If searing steak is the whole point of the purchase, read which grills actually sear before spending here.
- Real smoking. A gas grill can be coaxed into smoke with a box of chips, and smoker boxes is our page on exactly that, but nothing in this band is a smoker. If low-and-slow is the goal, grill smoker combos and electric smokers are the honest answers.
- Assembly you will enjoy. Every cart here arrives flat and takes an afternoon. The Royal Gourmet GG3001S is a listed 63.3 lb of parts; the Nexgrill-class carts are similar. The Weber Q is the exception — it arrives essentially built.
- Side shelves you can work on. Wire side shelves in this band are for staging a plate, not for prep. If that is the irritation, a prep table next to the grill fixes it for less than stepping up a grill tier.
Also under the band, and why they are not on the page
- Char-Broil Classic 360, the 3-burner. A registry product of ours and comfortably inside the band, with a published 360 sq in and side shelves. It is not on this page only because the Royal Gourmet GG3001S does the same job with porcelain-enameled cast-iron grates and a published area split, and two near-identical three-burners would pad the page. It is a perfectly good grill and it is on best gas grills.
- A 1-burner tabletop propane grill for camping. Far cheaper than anything here and genuinely the right answer for a campsite or a tailgate, but a single tabletop burner is a different product from a patio grill. It lives on best portable grills.
- Two unbranded four-burner carts. Both live and priced under $300 on 19 November 2026, both with higher BTU figures than anything on this page. Neither publishes a warranty length, a grate material or a brand with a parts history, and both ship from marketplace storefronts. More BTU from a brand that will not exist in three years is not a better grill.
- Tabletop griddles. Several sit in this band and they are excellent, but a flat top is not a gas grill — there are no grates and no flame contact. If that is the direction, see best flat-top griddles and best Blackstone griddles.
Buying one of these as a gift
A grill is one of the better big gifts and one of the riskier ones, so a few plain rules.
- Check where it will live before you check what it costs. Width is the constraint that bites: 53.7 in of cart does not fit a small balcony, and NFPA’s guidance is to keep a grill well clear of the house and the railing, which eats more of a small deck than people expect. On a balcony the Weber Q is the pick, and it is not a close call.
- Propane is a second purchase. Every cart here needs a 20 lb cylinder that does not come in the box, and the Weber Q is built around a 1 lb canister unless you add Weber’s adapter hose. Factor it in, or the gift cannot be used on the day it arrives.
- Somebody has to build it. If that person is not you and not them, this is the wrong gift at this price. Consider spending the money on a gift under $100 that works out of the box instead.
- The accessories that matter are cheap. A thermometer, a cover and a decent set of tongs turn any of these grills into a better experience than a more expensive grill without them. Our Thermapen alternatives page covers the first of those at every price point.
One last framing that is worth saying out loud: if the person you are buying for is new to grilling, the best grill in this band is the one they will actually light on a Tuesday. That is usually the simplest one with the fewest knobs and the fastest start, not the one with the most square inches. Our grills for beginners page is written from exactly that angle.