How we picked
Traeger makes this decision harder than it needs to be by naming models rather than sizes, so we ignored the names and compared four published numbers plus one question about software.
- Cooking area, split by rack. A single headline figure hides how usable a grill is, because the upper rack is a warming and low-and-slow shelf rather than a second grate. Traeger publishes both: 428 + 225 sq in on the Westwood, 520 + 340 on the Woodridge, 585 + 385 on the Woodridge Pro. The Tailgater is a single 300 sq in grate.
- Temperature ceiling. This is where pellet grills disappoint people who expected a grill. Traeger publishes 450°F on the Westwood and the Tailgater, 500°F on both Woodridges. None of those is a searing temperature, and no amount of money spent inside this line-up changes it.
- Hopper size, because it decides whether you sleep. 8 lb on the Tailgater, 18 lb on the Westwood, 24 lb on both Woodridges. A brisket is a twelve-hour cook; an 8 lb hopper is a grill you have to keep visiting.
- Warranty, the only long-term claim a maker makes. Traeger publishes 10 years on both Woodridges and 7 on the Westwood. On a cooker with a motor, an auger, a fan and a controller, that gap is the most expensive line in the comparison.
- Whether the app is included at all. Three of these four have WiFIRE. The Tailgater does not, and Traeger says so plainly. If someone is buying a Traeger specifically because they have seen the app, this is the spec to check before clicking.
Two things we did not judge on. Pellet flavor, because every grill here burns the same bags — that decision belongs on the pellets page, not this one. And reported owner opinion, because we have no way to verify it and will not dress it up as a test.
The four at a glance
| Model | Published area | Range | Hopper | App | Warranty |
|---|
| Westwood | 653 sq in (428 + 225) | 180–450°F | 18 lb | WiFIRE | 7 years limited |
| Woodridge | 860 sq in (520 + 340) | 180–500°F | 24 lb | WiFIRE | 10 years limited |
| Woodridge Pro | 970 sq in (585 + 385) | 180–500°F | 24 lb | WiFIRE + pellet sensor | 10 years limited |
| Tailgater | 300 sq in, single grate | 180–450°F | 8 lb | None - Digital Arc controller | Not published on this listing |
Every figure in that table is Traeger’s own. The one blank cell is blank on purpose: Traeger publishes no warranty length for the Tailgater on the listing we read, so we are not going to supply one.
Woodridge or Woodridge Pro? The money question
These two grills share a hopper, a ceiling and a warranty. The Pro adds 110 sq in, Super Smoke mode, a digital pellet sensor that reports hopper level to the app, Keep Warm, and a folding side shelf. That is a features upgrade rather than a cooking upgrade, and it is worth paying for in one situation: the person already smokes regularly on something else and cares about smoke intensity rather than capacity.
For a first pellet grill the plain Woodridge is the better use of the money, and the 860 sq in it publishes is more grate than most households ever fill. Traeger lists it at 138 lb and the Pro at 174 lb — worth knowing, because where either one gets assembled is roughly where it lives.
What a Traeger does not do, stated plainly
A pellet grill lights itself, holds a set temperature and makes its own smoke. In exchange it needs a 120V outlet — Traeger rates the Tailgater at 250 W — and it will not give you a dark, dry sear. Two honest consequences follow. Nobody should buy a Traeger for a campsite with no power; the Tailgater is portable, not off-grid. And if the cook mostly makes steaks and burgers, a gas grill or a charcoal kettle delivers more of what they want for less money.
It is also worth knowing what the price does not include. Neither a cover nor a bag of pellets is listed as included on any of these grills, and both are needed on day one — see covers and pellets. If the budget is tight, that is a reason to buy one tier down rather than to skip them.
Buying a Traeger as a gift
- Confirm there is an outdoor outlet first. This is the one question that turns a generous gift into a heavy box. Every grill on this page plugs in.
- Check whether they wanted app control specifically. If the answer is yes, the Tailgater is off the list regardless of price, because Traeger states it has no WiFIRE.
- Budget for pellets and a cover alongside it. A 20 lb bag and a fitted cover turn the present into something usable the same weekend.
- If the budget stops short, look at the competition rather than the smallest Traeger. Our Traeger alternatives page covers the cookers that match it on capacity, searing heat or price, and pellet grills under $500 covers the band below this one.