How we picked
This is a category with almost no published specification and a great deal of published adjective. Four things can be verified from a listing, and those are the four we used.
- Which of the three materials it is. Absorbent, wipe-clean or fireproof. Three of the six makers state it outright — Drymate says absorbent fabric, Brinman says absorbent, Cuisinart says polyvinyl chloride and UBeesize says fireproof. DiversiTech states no material on either of its listings, so both of its mats are grouped here as non-absorbent on the strength of what the listings do say, and that gap is printed in the table. Mats doing different jobs should not be compared on price.
- Published size, against the real footprint. Measure the grill including the shelves, then add about two feet in front of it, because that is where the drips land and where you stand. Depth is the dimension people get wrong: a 30-inch-deep mat under a 24-inch-deep grill leaves six inches of margin, which is nothing.
- Whether a deck type is named. Composite decking is the surface most likely to be permanently marked by grease and the surface a smooth mat is most likely to slide on. Exactly one mat here names composite decks on its listing, and that is why it is on the page despite being small for the money.
- Who stands behind it. DiversiTech and Cuisinart are named corporate manufacturers and Drymate states US manufacture. The rest are marketplace brands, which is fine at the price and worth knowing. One warning specific to this category: the similar-looking mats sold in hardware stores under the GrillTex name are a different company’s product, so do not assume a DiversiTech review applies to one or the other.
We also checked one mat we did not include. Weber sells an XL floor protection mat for grills and griddles, and it was in stock and priced when we looked — at roughly three times what the DiversiTech costs and four times the Drymate, for no published advantage in material, size or temperature rating. If brand-matching your mat to your grill matters to you, it exists. On a buyer-first basis we cannot point at it.
What each mat publishes, side by side
Every figure below is from the maker-supplied Amazon listing, read on 5 November 2026. “Not published” means the maker states no number.
| Mat | Published size | Material type | Deck type named | Temp rating |
|---|
| Drymate XL | 36 x 59 in | Absorbent fabric, waterproof backing | Deck and patio, no type | Not published |
| Brinman | 36 x 30 in | Absorbent, waterproof, reusable | Decks and patios, no type | Not published |
| DiversiTech BBQ & Fire Pit Mat | 60 x 30 in | Not published; sold as a grill and fire-pit mat | Deck and patio, no type | Not published |
| DiversiTech Ultra | 30 in | Not published; lightweight construction stated | Composite deck, stated | Not published |
| UBeesize fireproof | 65 x 48 in | Double-sided fireproof woven | Decks and patios, no type | “Fireproof”, no degrees |
| Cuisinart CGMT-300 | 65 x 36 in | Polyvinyl chloride, stated | Deck and patio, no type | Not published |
The empty right-hand column is the story of this category. Five of six makers sell heat protection without publishing a temperature, and the sixth publishes the word “fireproof” and no figure behind it. That is why the picks here are sorted by job rather than ranked by a heat spec that does not exist.
Grease is the problem, not fire
Ask people why they want a mat and most say fire. Ask what has actually happened to their deck and the answer is almost always grease: a dark halo under the grill that will not scrub out, boards that look oiled in a patch, and a trail of greasy footprints heading for the back door. That is the damage a mat genuinely prevents, and it is the reason the material choice matters.
On wooden decking, grease soaks into the timber and into the finish, and once it is in there it is in there — you can sand it or live with it. On composite decking, grease sits on a plastic surface that cannot be sanded, which is why composite manufacturers are explicit about cleaning spills quickly and why the one mat here that names composite decks exists at all.
An absorbent mat wins on wooden and composite decks for the same reason: the drip is captured where it lands, so nobody walks through it. The trade is honest — an absorbent mat gradually looks used, because it is doing its job. A wipe-clean mat looks new for years and requires you to actually wipe it, and if you do not, a puddle of fat sits on a slippery plastic sheet.
What a mat does not do
This is the part most pages in this category leave out, so we will be blunt about it.
A mat is not clearance. NFPA’s guidance is that the grill goes well away from the house and the deck railings, and out from under eaves and overhanging branches. A mat under the grill changes nothing about that geometry. On NFPA’s 2020–2024 annual averages, grills were involved in roughly 9,235 home fires a year, and nearly a quarter of grill structure fires started on an exterior balcony or open porch, with a further 8% beginning when an outside wall caught fire. The fix for those is distance, not a pad.
A mat does not make a covered balcony legal. Rules on grilling on balconies, porches and roofed decks are local and some are strict — several states and many apartment leases prohibit charcoal grills, or any grill under an overhang, outright. Check before you buy anything, and if you are in that situation our gifts for apartment grillers page is built around the constraint.
A mat does not stop a grease fire. Grease fires start in the grill, in the catch pan and in the burner area. Weber’s own prevention list is to trim excess fat, keep the grease catch-pan wiped clean, and cook with the lid down because a flare-up is unlikely when oxygen is limited. Our flare-up guide covers the rest. The mat is there for what drips out, not for what happens inside.
Sizing it properly
Nearly every complaint about these mats is a sizing complaint, and sizing is the one thing entirely within your control because every maker here publishes dimensions.
- Measure the grill with the shelves out. Folding side shelves are where sauce bottles live and where things get knocked over, and a cart grill is substantially wider with them deployed.
- Add standing room in front. Two feet is about right. You want the mat under your feet, because that is the surface that gets the drips off the tongs and the bottom of a plate.
- Watch the depth, not just the width. A 36 x 59 in mat laid with the long edge along the deck gives you plenty of width and plenty of depth. A 30-inch-deep mat may be width enough and depth nothing, depending how you lay it.
- For a griddle, go bigger than you think. A 36-inch flat top spatters over a wider area than a lidded grill ever does, which is why the 65 x 36 in mat is the pick for one. Our flat top griddles roundup covers the cookers themselves.
The honest case for buying nothing
If the grill sits on concrete, flagstone or pavers, you do not need a mat. Those surfaces stain, and a mat will keep them cleaner, but nothing is being damaged in a way that matters. Sweep it, hose it, move on.
If it sits on a deck, there is a free alternative people genuinely use: a purpose-cut piece of cement board or a couple of concrete pavers under the grill. It is ugly, it is heavy, it traps moisture against the boards if you never move it, and it does nothing for the two feet in front where you stand — but it costs very little and it is not nothing.
The real argument for a proper mat is the combination: it protects the deck, it catches what you drip while you are standing there, and it comes up and goes in the garage at the end of the season. The other half of that argument is a grill cover, which is the accessory that does more for a deck-mounted grill’s lifespan than anything else on this site and the one almost nobody buys until the first bad winter.
Buying this as a gift
A grill mat is an unglamorous present, and it is a surprisingly good one, because it is exactly the sort of thing people know they should own and never get round to buying.
- You need to know the surface. Wood deck, composite deck, balcony or patio changes the recommendation. If you do not know, the absorbent XL is the safest guess, because grease is the universal problem.
- It is a good second item, not a main one. Nobody’s face lights up at a mat. Paired with a cover, a brush or a bag of charcoal it reads as thoughtful and complete — see grilling gifts under $50 for pairings at that price.
- Perfect for a new homeowner. A new deck and a new grill is precisely the moment this matters, and the moment the owner has not thought about it yet. Housewarming grilling gifts is built for that case.
- Skip it for a charcoal purist with a yard. Grill on grass or gravel and a mat is clutter. Buy them charcoal baskets instead and they will actually use it next weekend.