Char Chimney

Masterbuilt Alternatives: 4 Smokers, and the Awkward Truth About Price

Masterbuilt sets the standard for cheap, easy electric smoking - and it is also cheaper than every alternative here. So buy one of these for a reason: more capacity, a longer warranty, a window, or higher heat.

By Stephen V.Last updated How we pick

Start with what Masterbuilt publishes, because it explains why this page is unusual. The 30-inch Digital (MB20071117) lists 710 sq in over four racks — Masterbuilt says 6 chickens, 2 turkeys, 4 pork butts or 4 racks of ribs — a digital panel you set and walk away from, a patented side chip loader that adds smoke without opening the door, under 50 lb at 33 inches tall, a 275°F ceiling and a one-year warranty.

The awkward part: the Masterbuilt 30-inch is cheaper than every alternative on this page. So nobody should switch to save money. Switch because you want something specific that Masterbuilt does not publish — and three of those things are real.

The closest overall alternative is the Pit Boss 4-Series electric vertical. Pit Boss publishes 1,320 sq in of cooking surface — nearly double the 30-inch Masterbuilt — a 1,650 W element, WiFi and Bluetooth through the Pit Boss app, one meat probe with two probe ports, rear wheels, and a three-year warranty, three times Masterbuilt’s. Pit Boss’s own documents disagree with themselves on two points and we print both: the spec sheet says 100–320°F where the product page says 100–300°F, and the spec sheet lists six racks where the retail title says four.

The budget pick is the Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker, which is the cheapest alternative here and deliberately dumb: Char-Broil publishes 544 sq in over three chrome-plated grates, a 1,200 W element in an insulated chamber with dual door latches, a door-mounted gauge and a one-year warranty on lid, grates and parts. No panel, no probe, no app — you set a dial and read a gauge. It is still more expensive than the Masterbuilt 30-inch, which tells you how keenly that cabinet is priced.

One thing this page will not do is pretend an electric cabinet replaces a Masterbuilt Gravity Series. A gravity-fed charcoal hopper is a different product with a different fuel, and we hold no gravity-fed cooker in our registry, so we are not going to substitute one. If that is the model you were looking at, the honest nearest answers are a pellet grill or an insulated charcoal cooker, not another electric box. We own none of this gear and claim no testing — here is exactly what we do instead.

How this is funded: we earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which gift we recommend, and we’ll tell you when we’d skip one. Full disclosure.

Quick picks

Our shortlist, with the price on every pick. Select a row to jump to the full write-up. We haven’t tested these ourselves — here’s exactly what we do instead.

#ProductBest forPrice
1
Pit Boss 4-Series WiFi & Bluetooth Digital Electric Vertical Smoker (11085)

Pit Boss 4-Series WiFi & Bluetooth Digital Electric Vertical Smoker (11085)

The most cooking space per dollar here by a wide margin: Pit Boss publishes 1,320 square inches, a 1,650-watt element, WiFi and Bluetooth, a meat probe with two probe ports, rear wheels and - the figure that actually matters over a decade - a three-year warranty where Masterbuilt gives one.

Closest overall - double the capacity, triple the warranty
$329.00 · View on Amazon

$399.9918% off

Price as of November 21, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

2
EAST OAK 30-Inch Electric Smoker with Window and Probe (EKESPR30)

EAST OAK 30-Inch Electric Smoker with Window and Probe (EKESPR30)

The cabinet that fixes the two things people complain about on a Masterbuilt: it has a clear viewing window and a built-in meat probe, and EAST OAK says it switches itself to keep-warm when the target is reached. The maker publishes 725 square inches, digital controls and a side chip loader it rates at six times longer between refills.

Best for a window and a built-in probe
$254.99 · View on Amazon

$299.9915% off

Price as of November 21, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

3
Pit Boss 500 FB2 Series Wood Pellet Grill & Smoker with Flame Broiler

Pit Boss 500 FB2 Series Wood Pellet Grill & Smoker with Flame Broiler

The lowest-priced full-size pellet grill on this page when we checked, and the one budget pick that can genuinely sear: a Flame Broiler lever opens the fire pot to direct flame, which Pit Boss rates to 1,000°F.

Best if you want higher heat and real wood
$399.97 · View on Amazon

Price as of November 21, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

4
Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (18202077)

Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (18202077)

The cheapest way into electric smoking, and deliberately dumb. Char-Broil publishes 544 square inches over three chrome-plated grates, a 1,200-watt element in an insulated chamber, a door-mounted gauge, dual door latches and a one-year warranty on lid, grates and parts. There is no digital panel, no probe and no app - you set a dial and read a gauge.

Budget pick - the cheapest alternative here
$223.47 · View on Amazon

$249.9911% off

Price as of November 21, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

The picks in full

#1Closest overall - double the capacity, triple the warranty

Pit Boss 4-Series WiFi & Bluetooth Digital Electric Vertical Smoker (11085)

The most cooking space per dollar here by a wide margin: Pit Boss publishes 1,320 square inches, a 1,650-watt element, WiFi and Bluetooth, a meat probe with two probe ports, rear wheels and - the figure that actually matters over a decade - a three-year warranty where Masterbuilt gives one.

Why it’s a good gift

  • 1,320 sq in of cooking surface, nearly double the 30-inch Masterbuilt
  • Three-year warranty, three times Masterbuilt's
  • 1,650 W element with WiFi and Bluetooth through the Pit Boss app
  • One meat probe included with two probe ports, plus rear wheels for moving it

Worth knowing

  • Pit Boss's own spec sheet says 100-320°F while its product page says 100-300°F
  • The spec sheet lists six racks; the retail title says four
  • Nearly 75 lb and 47 in tall - this is a cabinet that stays where you put it
  • Wood goes in a chip tray rather than a sealed side loader, so topping up is less tidy

Best for: The most capacity and the longest warranty for the money

Details read from the Amazon listing, last checked October 15, 2026. Prices change; the number above is fetched live.

#2Best for a window and a built-in probe

EAST OAK 30-Inch Electric Smoker with Window and Probe (EKESPR30)

The cabinet that fixes the two things people complain about on a Masterbuilt: it has a clear viewing window and a built-in meat probe, and EAST OAK says it switches itself to keep-warm when the target is reached. The maker publishes 725 square inches, digital controls and a side chip loader it rates at six times longer between refills.

Why it’s a good gift

  • Built-in meat probe tracks the internal temperature without opening the door
  • Clear viewing window, which Masterbuilt's 30-inch cabinets do not have
  • 725 sq in, slightly more than the 30-inch Masterbuilt
  • EAST OAK states it switches to keep-warm automatically at the target time

Worth knowing

  • A newer brand with nothing like Masterbuilt's or Pit Boss's parts history
  • No warranty length published on the listing
  • Sold by the brand's own storefront rather than Amazon, so returns run through them
  • EAST OAK publishes no readable spec page, so every figure here comes from the maker-supplied Amazon listing

Best for: Someone who wants a probe and a window built in

Details read from the Amazon listing, last checked October 15, 2026. Prices change; the number above is fetched live.

#3Best if you want higher heat and real wood

Pit Boss 500 FB2 Series Wood Pellet Grill & Smoker with Flame Broiler

The lowest-priced full-size pellet grill on this page when we checked, and the one budget pick that can genuinely sear: a Flame Broiler lever opens the fire pot to direct flame, which Pit Boss rates to 1,000°F.

A note before you buy. A strong pick for somebody who mostly wants weeknight burgers, chicken and the odd rack of ribs. For overnight brisket, the tiny hopper is the thing that will annoy them.

Why it’s a good gift

  • 518 sq in of two-tier, porcelain-coated steel cooking space
  • 180-500°F in 5°F steps from the digital controller
  • Flame Broiler lever for direct-flame searing up to 1,000°F
  • Two meat probe ports, one probe included
  • 5-year warranty

Worth knowing

  • A 5 lb hopper — the smallest on this page, so long cooks mean topping up
  • No WiFi or app control is listed for this model
  • 5-year warranty against 7 to 10 years on the Traegers

Best for: A first pellet grill on a tight budget

Details read from the Amazon listing, last checked September 17, 2026. Prices change; the number above is fetched live.

#4Budget pick - the cheapest alternative here

Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker (18202077)

The cheapest way into electric smoking, and deliberately dumb. Char-Broil publishes 544 square inches over three chrome-plated grates, a 1,200-watt element in an insulated chamber, a door-mounted gauge, dual door latches and a one-year warranty on lid, grates and parts. There is no digital panel, no probe and no app - you set a dial and read a gauge.

Why it’s a good gift

  • The lowest price of any smoker on this page
  • 1,200 W element in an insulated chamber with dual door latches, per Char-Broil
  • Nothing to pair, update or break in software
  • Carrying handles, so it moves and stores more easily than the tall cabinets

Worth knowing

  • An analog dial holds temperature far less tightly than a digital controller
  • A door-mounted gauge reads the air at the door, not the meat - they will still need a probe thermometer
  • 544 sq in is the smallest capacity here
  • No side chip loader, so topping up smoke means opening the door and losing heat

Best for: The cheapest honest entry into electric smoking

Details read from the Amazon listing, last checked October 15, 2026. Prices change; the number above is fetched live.

The three reasons to switch, and the one that is not a reason

  • Capacity. Masterbuilt publishes 710 sq in on the 30-inch and 970 sq in on the 40-inch. Pit Boss publishes 1,320 sq in on the 4-Series, which is nearly double the 30-inch cabinet. If the constraint is how much goes in at once, this is the clearest win available.
  • Warranty. Masterbuilt publishes one year on both the 30-inch and the 710 WiFi. Pit Boss publishes three. On an appliance with a heating element and a controller sitting outdoors, that is the single most meaningful difference on this page.
  • Seeing in without opening the door. Masterbuilt’s 30-inch cabinets have no window; the 40-inch does. EAST OAK’s 30-inch publishes both a clear viewing window and a built-in meat probe at 725 sq in, slightly more than the 30-inch Masterbuilt — which is a genuinely sensible combination at that size.
  • Price is not one of the reasons. Every alternative here costs more than the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital. If the budget is the constraint, the honest recommendation is to buy the Masterbuilt and spend the difference on a probe thermometer and wood chips.

The four, measured against the original

CookerPublished areaCeilingSmoke sourceWarranty
Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital (the original)710 sq in, 4 racks275°FPatented side chip loader1 year
Pit Boss 4-Series electric1,320 sq inSpec sheet 320°F / product page 300°FChip tray - opens the door to top up3 years
EAST OAK 30-inch (EKESPR30)725 sq inNot published on this listingChip tray; window and built-in probeNot published on this listing
Pit Boss 500 FB2 pellet grill518 sq in, two tiers500°F; lever rated to 1,000°FBurns wood pellets as fuel5 years
Char-Broil Analog544 sq in, 3 gratesNot published as a figure - analog dialChip pan, no side loader1 year on lid, grates, parts

Two rows carry a blank cell and one carries two numbers. EAST OAK publishes no warranty length and no readable spec page of its own, so every figure for it comes from the maker-supplied Amazon listing. And where Pit Boss’s own documents disagree — 320°F against 300°F, six racks against four — we print both rather than choosing the flattering one.

The side chip loader is the feature people miss

It is the thing Masterbuilt owners mention first when they switch, and it is easy to overlook on a spec sheet. Masterbuilt’s patented side loader lets you add wood chips without opening the door, which means you top up smoke without dumping the chamber’s heat. Both Pit Boss cabinets and the Char-Broil use a chip tray instead, and Char-Broil is explicit that topping up means opening the door and losing heat.

On a short cook that costs you nothing. On a ten-hour pork butt where the chips need refreshing several times, it is the difference between a stable chamber and a sawtooth temperature graph. If that feature is why you like Masterbuilt, the honest answer is that no alternative here replaces it, and the right move is to stay — see which Masterbuilt to buy.

If 275 degrees is the problem

It is a real limit and Masterbuilt does not hide it: a 275°F ceiling means poultry skin will not crisp, and finishing a chicken or a turkey is a job for the grill or the oven. None of the electric alternatives fixes this properly — Pit Boss publishes 300°F or 320°F depending which document you read, which is a little more and not a different category.

The actual fix is a different fuel. The Pit Boss 500 FB2 pellet grill publishes 180–500°F in 5°F steps plus a Flame Broiler lever rated to 1,000°F for direct-flame searing, and it burns wood rather than running an element with chips beside it. It is a different cooker with different habits — it needs an outlet, it has a 5 lb hopper, and it is more involved than a set-and-forget cabinet — but it is the honest answer to “I want to smoke and then crisp the skin on the same cooker”. Our electric smoker versus pellet grill comparison covers the whole trade.

What none of these change

  • They all need a real wall outlet. Masterbuilt warns specifically against running its cabinet on an extension cord, and the same caution applies to a 1,650 W Pit Boss element.
  • They are all tall, heavy and permanent. Pit Boss lists the 4-Series at nearly 75 lb and 47 inches tall. The Char-Broil is the only pick here with carrying handles.
  • A door gauge is not a thermometer. The Char-Broil’s door-mounted gauge reads the air at the door rather than the meat, so a probe thermometer is not optional with it — and it is worth owning with any of them.
  • Wood is a consumable, and the format matters. An electric cabinet’s tray is sized for chips, not chunks. Chunks are the wrong product for every pick on this page except the pellet grill, which takes neither.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to a Masterbuilt electric smoker?

The Pit Boss 4-Series WiFi and Bluetooth digital electric vertical. Pit Boss publishes 1,320 sq in of cooking surface - nearly double the 710 sq in Masterbuilt 30-inch - a 1,650 W element, app control over WiFi and Bluetooth, one meat probe with two probe ports, rear wheels and a three-year warranty against Masterbuilt's one. Two caveats worth knowing: Pit Boss's spec sheet says 100-320F where its product page says 100-300F, and the spec sheet lists six racks where the retail title says four.

Is there a cheaper alternative to a Masterbuilt smoker?

No - and that is the honest headline of this page. Every alternative we could verify costs more than the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital, including the deliberately basic Char-Broil analog cabinet. If budget is the constraint, buy the Masterbuilt and spend the difference on a probe thermometer and a bag of wood chips. Switch for capacity, warranty, a window or higher heat - not to save money.

What replaces the Masterbuilt Gravity Series?

Nothing on this page, and we will not pretend otherwise. A gravity-fed charcoal hopper is a different product with a different fuel from an electric cabinet, and we hold no gravity-fed cooker in our registry. The nearest honest answers are a pellet grill, which gives set-and-forget control and real wood at up to 500F, or an insulated charcoal cooker like a steel kamado, which gives charcoal heat retention. Both are different habits from a Gravity Series, not substitutes for it.

Which electric smoker has the biggest capacity?

The Pit Boss 4-Series, at a published 1,320 sq in - nearly double Masterbuilt's 30-inch cabinet at 710 sq in and well above Masterbuilt's 40-inch at 970 sq in. The practical cost of that capacity is footprint: Pit Boss lists it at nearly 75 lb and 47 inches tall, which makes it a cabinet that stays where you put it. It also uses a chip tray rather than Masterbuilt's sealed side loader, so topping up wood is less tidy.

Why does the side chip loader matter?

Because it lets you add wood without opening the door. Masterbuilt's patented side loader means you can refresh smoke mid-cook without dumping the chamber's heat, and no alternative on this page has it - both Pit Boss cabinets and the Char-Broil use a chip tray, and Char-Broil states plainly that topping up means opening the door and losing heat. On a ten-hour cook that is the difference between a stable chamber and a sawtooth temperature graph.

Can an electric smoker crisp chicken skin?

Not at Masterbuilt's published 275F ceiling, and not really at Pit Boss's 300F or 320F either - that is more heat, not a different category. Crisping skin is a finishing job for a grill or an oven. If you want one cooker to smoke and then crisp, the answer is a different fuel: the Pit Boss 500 FB2 pellet grill publishes 180-500F in 5F steps plus a Flame Broiler lever rated to 1,000F for direct-flame searing.

Is the EAST OAK electric smoker a good Masterbuilt alternative?

For one specific reason: it publishes both a clear viewing window and a built-in meat probe at 725 sq in, slightly more area than the 30-inch Masterbuilt, and EAST OAK states it switches to keep-warm automatically at the target time. Masterbuilt's 30-inch cabinets have no window. The caution is provenance: EAST OAK is a newer brand with nothing like Masterbuilt's or Pit Boss's parts history, it publishes no warranty length on the listing, no readable spec page of its own, and it is sold by the brand's own storefront rather than by Amazon.

Do electric smokers need a dedicated outlet?

They need a real wall outlet rather than an extension cord - Masterbuilt warns against extension cords specifically, and the same caution applies to the Pit Boss 4-Series at 1,650 W. This is a genuine siting constraint that people discover after delivery: a tall insulated cabinet, a long cook and a thin extension lead is the combination to avoid. Plan where it will live and what it will plug into before buying one.

Sources

  • Masterbuilt - 30-Inch Digital Electric Smoker (MB20071117) — Maker's specs: 710 sq in cooking space, four chrome-coated racks, 100-275°F digital control, 20.5 x 19.9 x 33.3 in, patented side woodchip loader, removable water bowl, adjustable air damper, fully insulated body with a lockable door latch, removable rear grease tray, 1-year warranty; capacity stated as up to 6 chickens, 2 turkeys, 4 pork butts or 4 racks of ribs. Wattage and weight are not published on this page (accessed October 15, 2026)
  • Masterbuilt - 710 WiFi Digital Electric Smoker (MB20070924) — Maker's specs: 711 sq in over four chrome-coated racks, 100-275°F, WiFi control of temperature, time, alerts and probes through the Masterbuilt app, support for up to 4 meat probes with 1 included, patented side woodchip loader, removable water bowl, adjustable air damper, lockable door latch on a fully insulated body, 1-year warranty, 40.6 x 22.3 x 22.9 in. Masterbuilt's product page does not serve an automated fetch, so it was read via live web search of that exact URL on 2026-10-15 (accessed October 15, 2026)
  • Masterbuilt - 40-Inch Digital Electric Smoker (MB20072918) — Maker's specs: 970 sq in cooking space, four chrome-coated racks, 100-275°F digital control, 25.6 x 19.9 x 41.3 in, viewing window, 1-year warranty; capacity stated as up to 16 chickens, 4 turkeys, 8 pork butts or 8 racks of ribs. Weight is not published. This page covers model MB20072918; the leg-kit variant sold as MB20070122 shares these figures but has its own model number (accessed October 15, 2026)
  • Pit Boss - 4-Series WiFi & Bluetooth Digital Electric Vertical Smoker (11085 / PBV42DS) — Maker's specs: 1,320 sq in total cooking space, 1,650 W element on 110-120V, WiFi and Bluetooth through the Pit Boss app, one meat probe with two probe ports, removable grease tray, exterior wood chip tray, rear wheels, 3-year warranty. Two of Pit Boss's own documents disagree: the 11085 spec sheet gives a 100-320°F range and six porcelain-coated racks, while the product page gives 100-300°F and the retail title says four racks. Pit Boss's product page does not serve an automated fetch, so it and the spec sheet were read via live web search on 2026-10-15 (accessed October 15, 2026)

Keep reading